Wow, if this is true, then The Bachelor TV show is truly heartless. Apparently, it was discovered after the first episode that Jason Mesnick picks Melissa Rycroft in the March 2, 2009 finale, but the plot thickens and it seems that Jason Mesnick actually dumps Melissa Rycroft in the After The Final Rose episode and selects Molly Malaney.
And it's not Jason Mesnick's fault: I'm guessing the producers of The Bachelor discovered that the show's sleuths did some investigating and figured out that the freckled hand and pinky ring in the ads belonged to Melissa Rycroft, so they told Jason Mesnick that he has to pick Molly Malaney in the aftershow.
That, or Jason Mesnick really is a prick and realized that the grass in greener. I was actually hoping that he would've picked DeAnna Pappas, but that's just me.
Post Title → Bachelor Finale Spoiler: Who Jason Really Picks